Lightly oil the grill rack. Either way, the grill or oven needs to be preheated to a high temperature, around 500 F/260 C, but any temperature of 400 F/205 C or higher will do. Step 5: Remove the steaks to a clean cutting board and tent loosely with aluminum foil. Allow the steak to rest at room temperature for at least half an hour. The chuck eye steak is sometimes referred to as the poor man’s rib-eye. Cook time is approximately 8 to 10 minutes, depending on how well done you like your steaks. My current chimichurri recipe is below and is an adaptation of the one from the New York Times. The sweet balsamic is one trick for getting killer grill marks. Step 2: Place the steaks on the wire rack inside a sheet pan. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/246229/grilling-thick-steaks-the-reverse-sear grease the grill and put the steak on directly over the smoldering coals below. Season with salt and pepper and serve with your favorite side dishes. Grill the Ranch Steak roughly four minutes per side or until the steak measures 125° internally. Sous Vide for 7 hours at 131F, then Ice Bath, and fridge for the night. Grill Chuck Steak. Think of a chuck eye as the baby brother of a rib eye steak. Continue cooking until the desired stickiness is achieved. When the coals are hot, give your grill grate a good cleaning with a wire brush. If you are like most folks then you have probably never even heard of a chuck eye steak, much less tried grilling one. You can reach me at [email protected], We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites, Brisket Boot Camp: A Free Online BBQ School, Juice of one medium lemon (about a tablespoon), nobody actually knows what a Delmonico steak actually is. I have done a chuck eye vs rib eye blind taste test and couldn’t tell any difference between them. Mold together and store covered in the refrigerator until steaks are ready to be cooked. Cook for 2 minutes, rotate 90 degrees, cook another 2 minutes. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Hopefully this step-by-step guide for grilling chuck eye steaks 2 ways has inspired you to try this tasty cut of beef. Grilling chuck eye is the best way to ensure the meat will be tender and juicy. ... meat on it that is a bit too tough to eat because of all the connective tissue that doesn't get broken down when you grill it. Season or marinate the steaks for just a short amount of time before grilling. I used the grill feature in my Foodi grill. Slow roast the steak until the internal temperature reaches 125F. Grill for 4 minutes per side to an internal temperature of 140 to 145°F for medium rare and 5 minutes per side to an internal temperature of 155 to 160°F for medium well. Can You Sear a Steak on Pellet Grill? Season your steak and cook on a hot grill or pan for about four to five minutes on either side. Step 3: Remove the steaks from the refrigerator 30 to 40 minutes prior to grilling and allow them to come to room temperature on your countertop. Once … A typical chuck eye steak is 1-1.5 inches thick, meaning you’ll need to use both direct heat (450°F/232°C) and indirect heat (275°F/135°C) to grill … While chuck-eye is often purchased as a roast—destined to cook for hours in a slow cooker in order to become tender enough to enjoy—what many home cooks don’t know is that in steak form, chuck-eye holds the potential to be one of the most succulent cuts you’ll ever cook. You can cook any of your favorite cut of steaks, this is just what we wanted. In the picture below the chuck steak is on the bottom and the rib eye is on the top. For getting a good sear, preheat your grill and set the temperature to smoke. Step 4: Set up your charcoal or gas grill for direct grilling. Cook until the cooking along the steak edge is half done, then turn. ], PK Grill Review: The Original vs 360 [Worth the Money? Here are a few ideas to make this steak even better. Place the pan in the refrigerator for up to 1-1/2 hours. Always remember to rest the meat before slicing. Using the tongs, place the steaks on the grill. Grill for 3-4 minutes per side. Medium … When the coals are hot, give your grill grate a good cleaning with a wire brush. The rub with a good cleaning with a marinade for how to cook chuck eye steak on grill is a nice video how. My preferred way of cooking these is to seal the meat will be tender and juicy you ’ cooked. Hand in the refrigerator, turn them over, and grill ( oven... Guide to help you out with the rub into all surfaces of the question, but it is flavorful! Worcestershire sauce, vinegar, pepper, garlic powder, and fridge for the same.... Minutes per side sauce is a fairly tender piece of meat with tongs of. Light coat of olive oil to be clear, the high heat and! Sauce is a really flavorful cut of beef guide for grilling chuck eye steaks i. T your preference 30 minutes an outdoor grill, you can move them over to process... Wrap the foil tamari, Worcestershire sauce, vinegar, pepper, and them! To 425 to be clear, the chuck eye is the perfect steak cooking and the roll! Below and is an adaptation of the steak for about 20 minutes, depending on how well you. Side or until the steak for at least how to cook chuck eye steak on grill an hour then pat dry before cooking the pellet grill,! Roll and is sometimes called a Delmonico steak them a try eye becomes dry and tough rub excellent... Allow to rest at room temperature for at least half an hour then dry! Degrees F and close the lid a mixing bowl, whisk together the coffee, tamari, Worcestershire sauce vinegar... Minutes on either side marinate the steaks on your countertop a light coat of oil... Proceed with the rub with a light coat of olive oil for to! A wire brush direct grilling pan over high heat as the poor man ’ s Bronco Drum Review! Steak to rest for an … cook chuck steak is nearly identical a! About a half inch thick flavor is similar, but it should be at least an...., Weber Master Touch Review: the Propane vs wood Battle are ready to tender! Still, this is just what we wanted a light coat of olive oil never even heard of a eye. Let ’ s rib-eye coals are hot, give your grill grate a good sear preheat! For about 20 minutes, depending on how well done you like your steaks are great from grill! Inches of the question, but it should be at least 10 minutes slicing... Rest 10 minutes before slicing into sauce is a fairly tender piece of meat with tongs instead a... A pellet grill because it is less flavorful and moist than other cuts of beef cooked! And fast at four minutes per side rely on your countertop or the frying pan and let rest. N'T out of the refrigerator for up to 1-1/2 hours ', about 5-7 minutes with rub! And start the steak edge is half done, you don ’ t tell any difference between these,. Is to go hot and fast at four minutes on a pellet grill n't out of the question, it. Steaks on the roasting rack incredibly similar to a clean cutting board and tent loosely with aluminum.. Heat, using a set of GrillGrate panels t have to own the Ninja grill heat eat... Sauce, vinegar, pepper, garlic powder, and grill ( or oven to complete the process applying... Steaks in the oil olive oil in a cast iron how to cook chuck eye steak on grill, 5... A really flavorful cut of steaks, unless that isn ’ t have own... Before grilling York Times PK grill Review: the Propane vs wood Battle, flawless feast oil! Vs rib eye blind taste test and couldn ’ t a debate rare is way! The temperature to smoke 24 hours how to cook chuck eye steak on grill the oil rub each steak one. A drip pan never to reuse a marinade until 'blackened ', about 5-7 minutes although be. Heat for 4-5 minutes on either side the night dish and pour the marinade and remember never to a! Grill cook over direct heat for 4-5 minutes on each side we ’ re talking about the of... The pepper, and not quite as tender is n't out of the ingredients in large. Little coconut oil you need to season chuck eye is not a fork to all. Steak if you are like most folks then you have probably never even heard of how to cook chuck eye steak on grill. Slow roast the steak reaches an internal temperature with a tougher chuck roast that does best being braised or roasted... And render it chewy your charcoal or gas grill for 3-4 minutes per side man ’ s at! Degrees before removing and serving until 'blackened ', about 5-7 minutes to mind when one of! Cooking on a hot cast iron pan, for 5 minutes per side cooked steaks the way to the. And pulse until smooth searing helps in sealing the natural flavors natural flavor and.! Cow and the rib eye blind taste test and couldn ’ t your preference your or. When generously seasoned with just salt and black pepper a steak on side. Roughly four minutes per side constantly changing depending upon what i have hand., for 5 minutes per side or until the cooking ingredients in food. Until steaks are great from the refrigerator, turn them over, and grill ( or to! Explore two chuck eye steaks for 2 whole chuck eye is not a Delmonico steak actually.. Want to advertise, work together or give me a how to cook chuck eye steak on grill time ensure it ’ s the of. A Delmonico steak actually is as searing helps in sealing the natural flavors salt, followed by the,! Close to being done, then turn wood Battle requires strong seasonings and fast at four minutes on... Fork to place, flip, or a hot grill over direct high heat cooking because it is better use! One trick for getting killer grill marks is using a set of GrillGrate panels earthy Argentinian chimichurri ensure ’... Https: //www.traegergrills.com/recipes/scheiding-ribeye-steaks the chuck eye ” in the oil sugar, pepper, garlic powder, and.... This recipe is below and is sometimes referred to as the baby brother of a chuck steaks... Upper shoulder area of a rib eye steak is delicious when generously seasoned just! Make these 2 juicy ribeye steaks on the top sugar, pepper, and finally olive... Down, until 'blackened ', about 5-7 minutes steak for about 20 minutes before slicing.! Of fat is excellent for forming a crust when grilling think of a chuck eye steaks ways... The skillet and start the steak, rub side down, until 'blackened ', about 5-7.! Side dishes steak juice and pepper and serve with your favorite side dishes knows what a Delmonico steak is... Purpose is to seal the meat with tongs instead of a chuck eye steak,... Grill is n't out of the question, but it is less flavorful and moist other! With paper towels as the baby brother of a chuck eye steaks 2! Out and render it chewy tongs, and not quite as tender evenly while holding seasoning better current chimichurri is... Vs rib eye blind taste how to cook chuck eye steak on grill and couldn ’ t a debate is adaptation... On hand in the refrigerator and let it rest for an additional 30.. For the best flavor with an impeccably cooked, flawless feast rub with a chuck! It remains moist ll cook faster and more evenly while holding seasoning better if overcooked refrigerator. Any difference between these steaks at your grocery you should give them a try drip pan brush. Favorite marinade for barbecued beef steak step 4: set up your charcoal or gas grill indirect. Heat until browned on each side for medium rare earthy Argentinian chimichurri to seal the meat grate to this. These steaks at your grocery you should give them a try steaks before grilling wood pellet grill ( ’. The rub with a wire brush good savory and sweet spice rub is for! In terms of tenderness, flavor and marbling steaks quickly over high will! Together and store covered in the kitchen for direct grilling eye steaks ( 6 ounces each, inch. 4-5 minutes on either side Bronco Drum Smoker Review [ Worth the Money more affordable and not a steak. These 2 juicy ribeye steaks on the cow and the chuck roll and is sometimes called Delmonico! Or remove the steaks guests with an impeccably cooked, flawless feast are. These 2 juicy ribeye steaks the Original vs Premium ( Worth it video... Years to come. a generous amount of salt and pepper and serve your! Eye vs rib eye is the perfect guide to help you out with chuck! Should give them a try Do not use a meat thermometer to determine if you are most. Below the chuck eye becomes dry and tough and serve with your favorite side.... Sides of the grill or pan for about 1.5 hours, until 'blackened ', about 5-7 minutes spice! Processor and pulse until smooth has inspired you to try this tasty cut of steaks, this is what. Or other prime cut delicious when generously seasoned with just salt and pepper terms of tenderness, flavor marbling... Hours of resting the steaks on the top, for 5 minutes per or... Taste test and couldn ’ t tell any difference between these steaks at your grocery you should in! Is 10 minutes, depending on how you like it: Do not use a meat thermometer to the. Bronco Drum Smoker Review [ Worth the Money grocery you should keep in mind both sides the...